Wikia

SGCommand

Talk:Stargate

Back to page

11,138pages on
this wiki

For an archive of this talk page, for the sake of viewing previous discussions before 2012, click here.

Travel direction Edit

The article says that the one-way travel of matter is a technological limitation, not a property of the wormhole. The show seems to indicate otherwise. Carter even comments on wormhole directionality in an academic setting in “Prodigy”. A fundamental property of wormholes makes more sense than gates only being able to deconstruct or reconstruct, especially since that’s contradicted by the shows several times. — Alecperkins(talk) (Contribs) 17:35, May 7, 2014 (UTC)

Recieving gate showing adressEdit

Alright strange question that came to mind while writing some FF.

What happens when a gate is dialled and it spinns:

  1. It spins to lock onto its own adress to show that it is the gate being dialled from somewhere else.
  2. It spins to lock onto the dialing gate's address to show what address it is being dialled from.


As I see it there is information to show for both cases. SGC personnel seem to be able to identify who's coming in before the wormhole has been established which could be due to them knowing what teams are off world and when they're due back. At other times they seem oblivios until they get radio conntact, a GDO code or another transmission.

Now according to the physics I was thought in school two or three years ago all energy is and can be threated as vibrations of some sort so here's a very simple way of seeing things. Matter is only allowed through from the dialing gate while energy(vibrations) are allowed in both directions. 

If you have two aluminium cans (representing the two event horizons) and a rubber tubing between them (the wormhole) and you (dialing gate) are asked by someone (the DHD) to send a liquid (the transfered matter) to someone else (recieving gate) through the tubing. Then you could basically throw the other end to the reciever and start pumping the liquid, they would not need to know who was sending the liquid, because it is the reciever's jobb to take the liquid it would be satisfied that it has recieved it and it would not have to ask who sent it to do its job. If we stretch the tubing we will now have a medium through which we can send vibrations back and forth, but the reciever will still not know who is causing the vibartions unless the sender choses to identify him.

Of course this is extremely different from actuall wormhole physics, yet I believe it to be an addequate comparisson for this question and if it is then there is nothing that would require the sending gate to tell the recieving gate to tell its address, meaning that the recieving gate can not spin/dial to show the address of the calling gate.


Any thoughts and/or ideas about the subject?

W1553 (talk) (Contribs) 23:35, April 12, 2016 (UTC)



Amelius didn't invent Stargates ?Edit

What you think ?


I think that Amelius didn't design first stargate. At least he didn't formulate it the night before the Alterans left their home galaxy, because how else Ori could had stargates unless they shared that technology before Alterans split to two faction ?

It could been that he had invented something related to stargates, but not stargates themselves.


Blomstar (talk) (Contribs) 18:25, June 25, 2016 (UTC)

It is possible, like many new technologies in real life, that the stargate is one of many creations resulting from the cumulative increase in technological advancements made by prior scientists over time, each contribution eventually leading up to the creation of the stargate devices. If this is the case with the stargates then the ancestors of the Ori and Ancients would have shared the same technologies and eventually made their own. As shown when they compared Ancient and Ori energy crystals that were comparable in power and shape but ultimately different from being separated for so long. The fact the Ori also have transporter rings, one of the precursor technologies to stargates, is another factor to take into account.
In this case, Amelius would have simply been an important figure and creator responsible for creating stargates on our side of things, taking the "fame" with him as well.
It may explain why the Ori created the supergates (a variant of their own version of a stargate) while the Ancients never did (which would have proven ridiculously useful for fast travel between galaxies) or at least it was never mentioned or theirs were destroyed by blackholes a long time ago. It is also possible that the Ori simply reverse engineered Ancient stargates rather quickly.
Anyways, these are just my thoughts on the matter, thinking out loud.
Ad infinitum et ultra! (talk) (Contribs) 20:35, June 25, 2016 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki